The complete issue

Vol. IX, No. 2
(32 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
Sgt.Maj. Alexander Bird of the 154th New York Infantry, the subject of one of the articles in this issue of Military Images, is shown with his wife, Melissa, in an albumen photograph.

Editor’s Desk (p. 1)
The editor suggests that readers in favor of preserving Civil War battlefields subscribe to The CWRT Digest, so that other battlefields do not fall to the same fate as Chantilly in Virginia.

Mail Call (p. 3)
The letters to the editor begins with a lengthy letter about the “off-beat” images found in the previous issue’s “Stragglers.” The author explains how carte de visite images can be manipulated with the original image switched with another in order to preserve a good backing. He suggests looking at other images from the same photographer to see if there is similarity with backdrops or even wall moldings or other features to authenticate a questionable image. Another letter provides additional information on the fate of Corporal Warren Alger (also in the previous issue); the author of this letter has access to a diary of another soldier who mentioned his sudden death. Other letters include the answer to Pop Quiz #320, which was an Italian Rifle Guards unit from Manhattan’Little Italy in the 1920s.

Passing in Review (pp. 4-5)
Six different publications are offered for review, beginning with the reprinting of the Recollections of a Naval Officer by Captain William H. Parker, which tells his story from joining the U.S. Navy at the age of 15, to his anguished decision to join the Confederacy, to several important naval battles, to his accompanying the refugee Confederate leadership from Richmond at the end of the war. Next is Confederate Shipbuilding by William N. Still, Jr. This book describes the failed attempt of the Confederacy to build a navy. The editor notes that readers interested in Still’s book should look also at “Phantom Fleet: The Confederacy’s Unclaimed European Warships” by David Sullivan in Warship International (vol. XXIV, no. 1). Third in review is Historic Dress of the Old West by Ernest Lisle Reedstrom, which is divided into different chapters devoted to different aspects of Western life. The review notes that there are numerous errors in the book that limits its value, however readers of MI might be interested in the nicely written overview of the life of frontier soldiers. Next is the review of Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War by Gerald F. Linderman. This volume describes the transition of the concept of “courage” between civilians and soldiers; the civilians maintained their definition without change, while the soldier, who was living the reality of war, changed his definition. Linderman posits that the divergence in definition remained until several years after the war, when the memories of the soldiers who survived softened over time and returned to an accord with the civilian definition. World Bayonets 1800 to the Present: An Illustrated Reference Guide For Collectors by Anthony Carter is next, and though the title is a bit misleading (only British bayonets are covered with American and other nations’ bayonets starting in 1873), it may be of use as there are very few books like this that focus on bayonets. Last in review is Uniforms of the French Foreign Legion by Martin Windrow which not only presents the uniforms of the French Foreign Legion over time, but also tells the stories of many Legion groups, including the one which fought to maintain Maximillian of Austria on the Mexican throne in the early 1860s.

Warrant Officers: Naval Uniforms of the Civil War, Part VI by Philip Katcher (pp. 6-7)
The U.S. Navy warrant officer is a rank dating back to 1794, unlike the warrant officer in the U.S. Army, which is a creation of the twentieth century. The men who held these ranks had various titles, such as passed midshipmen, sailmakers, and many others. The article describes the uniform details for the rank of warrant officer, often indicated by the number of buttons or the cap badges, and provides six different images as illustration.

A Tailor-made Image by Richard K. Tibbals (pp. 8-9)
A sixth-plate tintype shows six men appearing to be at work at tailors, or are they? Various items used in tailoring are prominently displayed, but with two soldiers in the image and a feel of relaxation among the men makes it a curious image indeed. The author requests any further information from the readership that might give the image more context and meaning.

New Recruits: Images of Children in Uniform by Robert Kotchian, Michael Scharfman, and William Schultz (pp. 10-13)
The three collectors who submitted these images provide a glimpse into childhood. The first two pages are from the collections of William Schultz and Michael Scharfman, offering eight images of children in patriotic garb, including miniature uniforms of varying types. The eight images on the second pair of pages are from the collection of Robert Kotchian; they are gem-sized tintype images found in an album which dates from the time of the Civil War. Each of the boys wears a kepi with the initials “N.A.C.” on them, presumably identifying them as Newark Academy Cadets. The images range from the serious boy saluting the camera to the mischievous lad who is thumbing his nose! Additional information regarding these images is encouraged as well.

Vignette: Colonel Van Manning, 3rd Arkansas Infantry by Keith Bohannon (pp. 14-15)
The sixth-plate ambrotype of Col. Van Manning and his wife Mary Zilephro Wallace Manning does not tell the story of the commander of the only Arkansas unit to fight with the Army of Northern Virginia. One would hardly note that the young lawyer who had gathered the men known as the “Arkansas Travellers” temporarily led a Texas brigade through the terrible fighting at Sharpsburg and was seriously wounded. Joined as part of the Texas Brigade, Manning fought on Houck’s Ridge during the second day of fighting at Gettysburg and led his Arkansans on a desperate charge, which left him wounded once more as a shell exploded right into his face. He led men at Chickamauga, Longstreet’s Knoxville campaign, and then returned to Virginia to fight in the Wilderness. Here he was wounded once more, and captured. He was hospitalized and then in August 1864, he led other men in the capture of the ship transferring him and 600 other prisoners – “The Immortal 600” – but the effort failed, and Col. Manning was imprisoned under close quarters. Again he annoyed his Federal captors by encouraging his fellow captives to refuse to sign the Oath of Allegiance, even after Lee surrendered; Manning would cut off the buttons from the uniforms of the “traitors” who did sign. Finally released in July 1865, Manning did have a successful post-war career as a lawyer and U.S. Congressman.

Every Picture Tells a Story: Outdoor views from the collection of Kean Wilcox (pp. 16-23)
Thirteen different outdoor images are featured in this article, which gives the reader some unique glimpses into the life of a Civil War soldier, from the quarter-plate tintype of soldiers in the process of breaking down their camp, to another quarter-plate tintype of what appears to be a new unit at training camp, to a sixth-plate tintype of Yankee troops with their camp set up in a town. Some of the images are portraits taken in outdoor settings, while one of the collection includes no images of humans at all – just the view of a camp with campfires burning and horses tied out in the woods. One intriguing image is of several Federal artillerymen relaxing with two small black boys in kepis in the front of the group and an unknown house on a hill in the background.

The 14th Brooklyn: A look at a unique uniform by Martin Schoenfeld (pp. 24-25)
The uniform worn by the 14th Brooklyn is truly a different one than those normally worn by Federal soldiers during the Civil War. It is distinguished by its chasseur leggings, red trousers, and a blue jacket with inversed red chevrons at the bottom of the sleeves and Russian knots on the shoulders. The jacket is unique also in that it had “false vest panels” down the front; the jacket was button closed at what looked like a vest, while the two false panels with as many bright brass buttons appeared to be the open jacket. The waist belt finished the look.

Vignette: Alexander Bird, 154th New York by Mark Dunkelman and Michael Winey (pp. 26-27)
The authors trace the service of Alexander “Alec” Bird after his enlistment as corporal in Company G of the 154th New York Volunteers in the summer of 1962. He was a blacksmith and farmer, and had recently married Melissa Ada Hyde, with whom he is featured on the cover of this MI issue. His diaries indicate that there were six images taken of himself during the course of the war, however the authors of the article have only located three at the time of this publication. The article includes one taken as a lieutenant in Savannah, Georgia on December 31, 1864 and a carte de visite taken at the time of his mustering out in June 1965 in Elmira, New York. He was in the fighting at Chancellorsville, where he also contracted the typhoid fever that kept him from joining his unit during the first day’s fighting at Gettysburg. Alec also took part in Sherman’s “March to the Sea” as well as doing duty in New York encouraging enlistments.

Stragglers (pp. 28-31)
This issue’s “Stragglers” include an unpublished carte de visite image of General Philip Kearney along with a quarter-plate tintype of an unidentified soldier with the knees of the next to be photographed in the margins of the image. There are three different sketches made of the charge of the 6th Michigan cavalry at Falling Water on July 14, 1863; two are by Edwin Forbes for Harper’s Weekly and one is by famed combat illustrator Alfred R. Waud. One fortunate collector found two images of the same soldier, one in dress and undress uniforms, at two different places. Lastly, Pop Quiz #322 shows former Confederate Brigadier General Alexander Welch Reynolds in 1869, wearing his uniform of colonel in the Egyptian Army.

Back Image
A quarter-plate tintype features three cavalrymen, complete with Gallagher carbines.

The complete issue

Vol. IX, No. 1
(32 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
The cover of this issues of Military Images features a carte de visite image of two compatriots working for the Veteran Reserve Corps. They wear the XXII corps badge that indicates their service in the defense of Washington, D.C.

Editor’s Desk (p. 1)
The editor discusses the loss of the Chantilly Battlefield site to development, and supports the protection of the Antietam site from the same fate.

Mail Call (p. 3)
Clarifications regarding identifications of images are provided by readers. Additional information about sharpshooters in Michigan brigades is also included. Subscribers are reminded to send in updated address information as soon as possible so their magazines do not go “absent without leave.”

Passing in Review (pp. 4-5)
There are seven publications offered for review in this issue of MI beginning with Illustrated Catalog of Civil War Military Goods by Schuyler, Hartley & Graham, an unabridged reprint of the 1864 catalog by the aforementioned New York firm. Next under review is Carl Bornemann’s Regiment, the 41st New York Infantry (DeKalb Regt.) in the Civil War by Dr. David G. Martin, which outlines the history of one of the regiments of “cowardly Dutchmen” which shows they were anything but. Some diary entries, photographic images, and sketches as well as some short biographies of regimental officers are also included. Civil War Generals: Categorical Listings and a Biographical Directory is compiled by James Spencer and shows the kind of database listing that could be compiled with the use of a computer at the date of publication of this issue. The Official Records of the Union and Confederate Armies is offered in 128 volumes and The Confederate Veteran in 40 volumes are made available by the Broadfoot Publishing Company, providing the essence of basic research information on the Civil War. These volumes are of considerable value to those doing extensive research on the course of the Civil War. Civil War Books: A Priced Checklist is compiled by Tom Broadfoot, Marianne Pair, and Roger Hunt, providing the collector of books a means to find a book’s comparative value. The checklist includes over 7000 titles in 10,000 volumes. Next in review is British Military Longarms, 1715-1865 by D.W. Bailey, providing an excellent overview of this very popular Confederate and second popular Federal firearm, as well as information from the Revolutionary and antebellum eras as well. Finally, the publication Why the South Lost the Civil War by Richard E. Berlinger, Herman Hattaway, Archer Jones, and William N. Still, Jr. is reviewed. The authors state that the South did not need to end the war as they did at Appomattox, but for three factors: absence of a sense of Southern nationalism, a religious belief that led to a sense of defeat/guilt, and a change in the nature of the government in Richmond. The reviewer sees the book as more of an “academic” work as opposed to a historical work.

The Faces of War: A series of vignettes (pp. 6-13)
Eleven different Military Issues vignettes are provided here, with an image and a short biography of each soldier:

• “James T. McElvaney, 35^th Georgia” by John and Robert Bailey
• “Warren Alger, 15th Massachusetts” by Randy Beck
• “Harvey Seeley, 6th Michigan Cavalry” by John Braden
• “Abashe Cowen, 62nd Pennsylvania” by Timothy Brookes
• “Velorous Bruce, 17th Michigan” by Bill Christen
• “William Masten, 1st Btn., North Carolina Sharpshooters” by Robert Fulmer
• “Lowell Mason, 42nd Massachusetts” by Norman Delaney
• “Oren C. Hull, 30th Wisconsin” by Douglas Hennig
• “George Lang, 3rd New Hampshire” by Wendell Lang
• “David Holmes, 6th Mississippi” by Barry Mickey
• “Charles Baldwin, U.S. Navy” by John Sickles

A Modest Hero: Sgt. Philip Decker at Cedar Creek by Seward R. Osborne (pp. 14-15)
Having entered the military in September 1862 at age 37, leaving his only daughter behind, Philip Decker enlisted as a sergeant in the “Mountain Legion,” Company E of the 156th New York Volunteer Infantry. By the time they left the Western part of the war and moved into the Eastern Theater in Virginia in the summer of 1864, their battle flag had been torn and tattered, in some cases pieces were pinned together. The “Mountain Legion” was just starting to get into line of battle before dawn at Cedar Creek when a number of other VIII Corps soldiers burst through their lines, followed by the Confederates of Kershaw’s 53rd Georgians. The color bearer went down as firing came at them from front and flank; Decker reached for the colors and made his stand at two Georgians with their own colors tried to wrest the banner from Sgt. Decker. He pulled the silken fabric from the standard, leaving the Georgian with the staff. Decker was downed by a shot in the elbow, giving up the colors to his captain, Alfred Cooley, who passed the tattered silk to Brig. Gen. Alfred Neafie, who carried the colors on his saddle for the remainder of the fighting at Cedar Ridge. Neafie sent the remnants home to his wife; the flag was eventually sent back to Cooley who kept it until it was dedicated at a reunion and dedication of the 156th monument at Highland, NY in 1908, with Sgt. Decker taking part in the ceremonies.

Rally Round the Flag: Images of Old Glory on her birthday compiled by Irena Zagoff (pp. 16-25)
A total of 31 different American flags from the Civil War era (with one exception) are presented in this pictorial article. The flags range from the human flag made by St. Paul, Minnesota school children wearing red, white, or blue hats taken in 1896 to an image of the famous American Eagle from the 8th Wisconsin, Old Abe, in front of Old Glory, to the typical tintype or carte de visite images of soldiers that have a flag in the background or wearing pins or badges. There are many examples of battle flags, torn and worn from their service on the Civil War battlefield, such as that of the 18th Connecticut, which had all of their major battles and dates inscribed on the red and white stripes or that of the 103rd Ohio, held by the “daughter of the regiment.”

A Flag for the Iron Brigade by William Gladstone (p. 26)
The “Iron Brigade” was made up of soldiers from Wisconsin, Indiana, and Michigan and citizens from those states commissioned Tiffany & Co. of New York to create a flag for the regiment. The article describes the details of the flag, from its rich dark blue silk to flags designating major battles through Gettysburg. The story of the flag’s presentation is told as well, with the ceremony being delayed a few days from its original anniversary of Antietam as the unit was called away to fight in Culpeper, Virginia. It is currently held in the War Museum of the Wisconsin State Capitol in Madison.

Stragglers (pp. 29)
The feature begins with a pair of pairs – one pair of militia or early Civil War musicians in a sixth-plate ambrotype sharing the page with a pair of images of Sergeant and Mrs. Abraham Cole of the 61st New York. “Pop Quiz #321” asks readers to identify an outdoor image, which would be easy for anyone from the Baltimore area. And three stragglers are presented as not quite what they seem to be; all are purported to be images of a hussar, Civil War wounded, and a pair of Confederates. They are probably images of actors, rather than the reality they purport to show.

Back Image
A war-weary image of a soldier in a sixth-plate tintype.

The complete issue

Vol. VIII, No. 6
(32 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
This issue’s cover features a Pennsylvania Bucktail holding his Enfield rifle in a sixth-plate tintype.

Editor’s Desk (p. 1)
The editor tells the story of a family treasure that got lost – someone in the family left a photo album of Uncle Isaac who served in the Civil War from 1862 to the end of the war in a train somewhere about 1957. He makes the point that while the images have significant family value, they are not remarkable. Remarkable images are those that provide new insight into the conflict, and the editor estimates that Military Images publishes on average one remarkable image per year. He believes one of these images to be the subject of the article beginning on page 6.

Mail Call (p. 3)
Many readers wrote to congratulate MI on the previous issue, which featured images from the collection of Ronn Palm. One reader provided some additional identifications for some of the images. Additional information regarding John C. Black and his brother William was also provided in a note from Brian Pohanka. One reader complained about the use of the term “kepi” with reference to “forage caps.”

Passing in Review (pp. 4-5)
A trio of reviews are presented in this issue, beginning with Checklist of Western Photographers: A Reference Workbook by Carl Mautz. This booklet intends to list all of the major photographers whose work focused west of the Mississippi in the 19th century. Space is left for new finds, which readers are encouraged to submit to the authors. The reviewer finds a lack of information on the eastern Western states. Next is The Photograph Collector’s Pocket Handbook by Doug Wahlberg, which does not receive high marks from the reviewer. It provides the names and basic biographies of major photographers, but only a range of value for the photographer’s individual work. In the case of Mathew Brady, this was from $50 to $10,000, which does not provide much guidance for collectors. Third in the group is Marylanders in the Confederacy by Daniel D. Hartzler, whose work attempts to list all of the men from Maryland who served in the Confederacy. While the estimate is about 25,000, the author lists 12,000 names with unit, highest rank, Maryland residence, and source of information. Other information that might be of interest (details of service such as wounding or death, battles, etc.) are not included.

A Scene in the Woods…: Analysis of a Rare Gettysburg Photograph by Harry Roach (pp. 6-9)
Published for the first time ever is one of the missing images from Alexander Gardner’s catalog of 1863 Civil War images. Shown along with images 245, 246, and 274 that have been clearly placed on the Rose Farm ground by the previous work of William Frasanito, this article presents Gardner’s stereoview image number 240 from the collection of Jeff Kowalis, as well as two magnified images. One image from the Alexander collection is still missing, however this particular image has been clearly identified as also having been taken from the same area as the previously identified images. The article also includes a map of the area, showing where the bodies of the dead were laid out for burial and where the cameras were likely placed. The article also makes the assertion that the dead were Union soldiers from the brigade led by Colonel John R. Brooks made up of a composite of the 2nd Delaware, 64th New York, 53rd Pennsylvania, part of the 145th Pennsylvania, and part of the 27th Connecticut.

A Soldier of Semmes’s Brigade: Robert N. Richardson, 53rd Georgia Volunteers by Keith Bohannon (p. 10)
This vignette tells the story of a “soldier of Semmes’s Brigade” who was a fatal casualty of the fighting at Rose Woods. Robert N. Richardson was a 38 year old farmer who had enlisted in the Quitman Guards in May 1862. Although ill for some time once he had been in the military, he rejoined his unit and eventually took part in this fighting at Gettysburg on July 2, 1863. He was shot in the thigh and eventually removed from the field, only to die in a Union hospital on August 11, 1863.

A Death in the Rose Woods by Orton Begner (p. 11)
A second vignette featuring a fatality from the fighting on the Rose Farm is about Captain Lieutenant Henry V. Fuller of Company F, 64th New York Infantry. The image shows him after his first promotion to the officer ranks in December 1861. Shot during the fighting and carried to the back as far as possible by one of his men, Fuller died on the field, his body being recovered on July 4th. He was buried at home in Little Valley, New York, and was brevetted full colonel in 1865. Members of his unit who survived the war erected a monument in his memory on the Gettysburg battlefield in 1894, only one of four company grade officers so honored.

The Fight for the Rose Woods: A Battle Narrative by Stephen Rogers (pp. 12-13)
This article is an excerpt from a forthcoming book by the author on the 64th New York, which took part in the fighting at Rose Woods as part of Brooke’s brigade, and provides a comprehensive narrative of what fighting took place at the Rose Woods after the Federal troops pushed the Confederates back across the Wheat Field. They were hit hard by the Rebels and began to retreat, only to turn into confusion along their lines. The article includes many recounted stories from survivors, including those left wounded overnight.

“Dear Brother Isaac…”: Letters from George Edgcomb, 15th New York Engineers edited by Edmund Raus (pp. 14-15)
In four letters, accompanied by a number of photographic images, the reader is given a glimpse into the time when the pontoon bridges were constructed across the James River by Union troops, including George Edgcomb, in June 1864. His letters provide comment on the activity in his camp as well as on the upcoming political elections and the possibility of his brother being called up in the next draft call.

The Jackson Guards: Company C, 149th Pennsylvania Infantry at Gettysburg by Richard Matthews (pp. 16-25)
A unit history of the Bucktail unit caught up in a controversy as a result of the fighting on the first day at Gettysburg. Calling themselves the “Jackson Guards,” Company C was made up of young men from the Myerstown Academy, with their principal, John Basseler serving as their captain. The article documents the group through training to become a Bucktail rifle brigade through the days leading up to July 1, 1863. The controversy dealt with the loss of the regimental flags during the fighting at the McPherson Farm. Basseler was able to bring the controversy to a conclusion with his collection of various statements from soldiers who were present. The article features 20 images of soldiers who took part in the fighting at the McPherson Farm, and provides a map that shows the positioning of the units on the field, including where the incident with the colors took place.

Bucktail Images by Ronn Palm (pp. 27-29)
Sixteen different images of Bucktail unit soldiers are featured in this pictorial article, with most of the subjects identified.. Ronn Palm provides a brief overview of the history of the Bucktail regiments and the so-called “Bogus Bucktails” who fought at the McPherson Farm as well.

Stragglers (pp. 30-31)
The submissions included in this edition of “Stragglers” includes an oval quarter-plate tintype of a young bugler set in front of a painted camp scene background. Another submission includes four soldiers in their winter coats in what appears to be an impromptu quarter-plate tintype image with many unique details. The last two images are part of “Pop Quiz No. 320.” The two full-body carte de visite images show two members of what is probably a New York militia company from probably the 1880s, complete with fancy feathered hats, intricate outdoor backdrops, and identification by the same photographer.

Back Image
A pair of images grace the back of the issue. One is a sixth-plate daguerreotype of an American dragoon with saber and horse pistols from about 1845-50. The second is an oval tintype image of Sewell Lawrence Fremont, found in the Asheville, NC area; the owners are requesting information about Fremont.

The complete issue

Vol. VIII, No. 5
(32 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
The ninth-plate ambrotype on the front cover is of a very young Zouave cadet, taken about 1861.

Editor’s Desk (p. 1)
The editor provides guidance on how to best copy images for submission to Military Images.

Mail Call (p. 3)
Some corrections to captions for some of the Ronn Palm images from the previous issue are noted, along with an explanation of why the magazine stands by the captioning in an article from the November-December 1986 issue.

Passing in Review (pp. 4-5)
A total of seven publications are reviewed in this issue of MI beginning with Bold Dragoon: the Life of J.E.B. Stuart by Emory M. Thomas. This work covers the entire life of Stuart and examines not only his successes, but also his failures as the cavalry chief of the Army of Northern Virginia. Simpson Speaks on History by Col. Harold R. Simspon is an anthology of six of the author’s public presentations on a wide variety of topics that would be entertaining for most readers. Flashman and the Dragoon by George MacDonald Fraser is the seventh memoir by Brigadier Sir Harry Flashman, this time with Flashman ending up in the midst of the Taiping Rebellion in 1860. Two reprinted volumes are reviewed together: The Custer Myth by W.A. Graham and With Custer’s Cavalry by Katherine Gibson Fougera. The first is a comprehensive collection of information about the Battle of Little Bighorn as of 1953 while the second is a memoir of one of Custer’s officer’s wife, providing an excellent glimpse into family life of the cavalry on the Plains. Custer’s Field: “A Scene of Sickening, Ghastly Horror” by Francis R. Taunton in collaboration with Brian C. Pohanka in its third edition is next, attempting to use archaeological as well as contemporary accounts of the battle to explain some of the questions about the battle. Finally, The Man Who Tried to Burn New York by Nat Brandt is reviewed. The book tells the story of Captain Robert Cobb Kennedy, late of the 1st Louisiana Infantry, and how he became engaged in the Confederate secret service plot to burn New York in 1864 in protest against the wealth of the city while the South was suffering from the war.

The Sharps Rifle in the Civil War by Richard Carlile (pp. 6-9)
The favorite weapon of Civil War sharpshooters, the article examines the acquisition of the Sharps rifle by “Berdan’s Sharpshooters” of the 1st and 2nd U.S. Sharpshooters. It began with Private Truman Head, known as “California Joe” of Company C, 1st Regiment of Sharpshooters, who purchased a M1859 model on his own. Not happy with their standard issue Colt five-shot revolving rifle, the men decided they liked the weapon, and Colonel Hiram Berdan pressured for its procurement. To keep it within cost, the rifles ordered by Berdan had some modifications; many Sharps rifles found in images are rarely the Berdan type. The article is accompanied by 12 images which show both Berdan and other manufactures of Sharps rifles.

Some Sailing Men… by John A. Stacey (pp. 10-12)
Eleven different images of sailors from 1866 to World War I show a variety of uniforms, often with non-regulation application of insignia. One photograph shows four soldiers on liberty, two of the soldiers being members of the same ship. They are, however wearing different names on their hat ribbons, as the German vessel Kronen Prinzess Cecilie was taken by the U.S. Navy and renamed the Mount Vernon; the names show the transition from one name to the other. Another image shows the mascot from the U.S.S. Ohio, the pet goat wearing several different naval insignia.

John C. Black: A Medal of Honor Winner from Illinois by Bill McFarland (pp. 13-15)
Beginning with two tintypes of a supposed Jacob Black of the Illinois Greyhounds, the author eventually came to the conclusion that the two images were of the man who eventually became General John C. Black, whose service during the Civil War began with a three-month enlistment in the Zouaves of the 111th Indiana. Afterward, the young man whose family was acquainted with Abraham Lincoln returned to Danville, Illinois and organized what became Company K of the 37th Illinois Infantry. John was the major of the regiment, his brother William a captain, and a step-brother a lieutenant. Both of the brothers were awarded the Medal of Honor for their actions (William at the Battle of Pea Ridge and John at Prairie Grove), the only pair of brothers other than Thomas and George Custer to be so recognized.

Zou Zou!: More photos of American Zouaves and Chasseurs by Irena Zogoff (pp. 16-21)
A compilation of 18 different images shows the wide variety and popularity of these types of units, from a pair of small boys in Zouave uniform, to a Collis Zouave in an image with his father, to a group of Zouaves frolicking for the camera. Captions to each image provide the reader with information regarding the uniform and its unit identification.

Other Zouave Images: Contemporary Lithographs as a Reference Tool by Howard Michael Madaus (pp. 22-24)
Using lithographs and woodcut images to identify Zouave units rather than only photographic images is the topic of this article. Many of these other types of images were taken from photographs, some of which are lost to history, such as the lithograph of the Tremont Zouaves of Massachusetts which was featured on a songsheet cover early in the Civil War. However, the image probably used to create a lithograph of a Zouave on an envelope is likely taken from an image of First Sergeant Louis N. Tucker of the “Boston Light Infantry” about 1861. There is enough similarity as well as a slogan used by Tucker’s unit (“Death or an Honorable Life”) to assume the connection. What the lithographs show that the photographic images do not is the coloration of the uniforms, allowing the modern viewer a more complete understanding of what these elaborate and unique uniforms looked like, making lithographs another source of information for the identification of Civil War uniforms.

Lt. Sydnum Bridgers: An Officer in the 47th North Carolina Infantry by Barry I. Mickey (p. 25)
The vignette of the soldier shown in the carte de visite image tells the story of a unit that was organized early in 1862 without weapons or many supplies, and did not see any real action until New Bern in May 1863. At Gettysburg, the 47th and Lt. Bridgers was part of Pickett’s Charge, led by General Pettigrew. Bridgers survived that charge, and was one of the 400 men left in his unit. It was in October at Bristoe Station in Virginia that Lt. Bridgers was wounded, and left on the field overnight. Transferred to one of Richmond’s military hospitals, Sydnum Bridgers died a month later.

Stragglers (pp. 27-31)
The “Stragglers” in this issue of Military Images presents eight different images from the humorous to those that have many questions arising from them. One of these is a scene that might be in California; the American flag in the image shows 28 stars under magnification, indicating that it probably comes from the Mexican War era. Another is of a soldier wearing a black hat with an ostrich feather including the letters “RRCS” and epaulettes that are made up of dark tight braid. Two other images show soldiers sitting on the ground; one can see that their boots include hobnails and heelplates.

Back Image
Two unidentified soldiers, one a Confederate and the other a Massachusetts militiaman, surround a sixth-plate daguerreotype of Lt. William Spencer, 2nd U.S. Infantry, from 1855-58.

The complete issue

Vol. VIII, No. 4
(32 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
A Union cavalryman plays his banjo from a sixth-plate tintype from the collection of Ronn Palm.

Editor’s Desk (p. 1)
This issue of Military Images is the first that is made up of selected images from one collection: “The Best of the Palm Collection.” Many of the included items are from his wide variety of images featuring Pennsylvania troops. The editor asks for feedback on this idea of featuring one person’s collection in an issue.

Passing in Review (pp. 2-3)
The five publications reviewed in this issue of MI begins with Historical Times Illustrated Encyclopedia of the Civil War, edited by Patricia L. Faust. This volume includes 2,000 entries that provide depth and detail that should appeal to the beginner and the experienced reader of Civil War information. It should be a companion to the Civil War Dictionary written by Mark Boatner. Second is The Cavalry at Gettysburg by Edward G. Longacre, who provides a long-needed description of the cavalry beginning in mid-June with Brandy Station through skirmishes leading up to the fighting at East Cavalry Field and the retreat ending in mid-July 1863. Longacre covers individuals like Stuart and Buford as well as others who are not as familiar to some readers. Third is The Fiery Trail, edited by Richard Harwell and Philp N. Racine, who take the letters and diary entries of Major Thomas W. Osborn of the Union Army of the Tennessee and provide them with detailed context and thus produce a detailed description of Sherman’s March. Fourth is The United States Navy: 200 Years by Edward L. Beach. Not intended to be a comprehensive history of the Navy, Beach looks at the people and incidents that had long-term impact on the future actions at sea, such as the fact that shots fired by the Monitor used only half charges. Last but not least is U.S. Army Uniforms and Equipment, 1889. This is a republication of the original Quartermaster Corps guide to all items ranging from barracks chairs to buttons, complete with line drawings and detailed descriptions. Collectors interested in this era’s items must have this publication.

Mail Call (p. 3)
Readers provided a few corrections from the survey of corps badges in the previous issue. One reader included an additional example of the crescent badge as worn by XI Corps, while another identifies an “unidentified” officer.

Interview with Ronn Palm (pp. 4-5)
The very first issue of MI in 1979 included a selection from his collection, and this issue begins with an interview with Ronn Palm. He discusses how he began collecting Civil War images and how he began to specialize in certain types of images. Part of the interview covers how he stores his collection of over 2,200 images of all types, as well as where he finds new images. He has made friendships with many dealers and most of his transactions now involve trading rather than outright purchases. The cost of images, he said, can be discouraging to new collectors, but he provides some suggestions for how new hobbyists can begin.

Infantry (pp. 6-11)
Ronn Palm’s image collection begins with 21 different images of Union soldiers who served in the infantry. The images range from carte de visite portraits of known and unknown individual soldiers to small group ambro- or tintypes images. A variety of uniform types and different weapons are displayed in these images. Most of the images have the typical backdrops used in period images, however one shows a soldier inside of a photographer’s tent, showing a very different glimpse of the era.

Zouaves and Chausseurs (pp. 12-14)
This selection of 10 images is also a mixture of individual and group portraits, including one that looks like it was taken outside, almost giving one the sense that it was taken during action. The wide variety of fancy and plain uniforms is shown as well. A pair of soldiers from the 62nd Pennsylvania shows how the uniform of that unit changed, from the plain uniform worn by Private Willis T. Benedict in 1861 to the epaulettes worn by Sergeant Abasha Cowen during his third year of service as noted by the chevrons on his sleeve.

Prisoners of War (p. 15)
Three images show both Union and Confederate prisoners of war. The group of five Confederates were held at Camp Douglas, Illinois, while the five Federal officers were held at Andersonville, Georgia. A single Connecticut soldier, Captain Billie Mays of the 23rd Connecticut, is shown upon his release from a POW camp in Texas; he has his gear and looks ready to go home.

Cavalry (pp. 16-21)
This section of the collection shows 22 different images of cavalrymen. Many of the images are individual portraits, with the first pages showing the men ready with a wide variety of weapons. While many of the men are unidentified, a few are known, such as Colonel Richard Rush and Captain Robert Mitchell, both of the 6th Pennsylvania Cavalry, also known as “Rush’s Lancers.” Palm’s collection includes some posed outdoor images with cavalry mounts, including two that show the same five men. In one image two are mounted while three lounge on the ground, their faces visible between the horses’ legs and bellies; they switch places in the next image. Colonel Alexander Hays and his staff (63rd Pennsylvania) are also featured in a half-plate tintype. The last five individual images in this section feature soldiers holding the M1855 pistol-carbine, a rare collector’s item and appears even more rarely in images, although it may be a photographer’s prop for these soldiers.

Musicians (pp. 22-23)
Indoor, outdoor, and in a tent are where the images of musicians were taken for these two pages. Featuring a trio of horns, a drummer boy, a bugler, and a band outside at parade rest join a pair of older militia musicians with fife and drum.

Outdoor Images (pp. 24-27)
At one time, outdoor images were a passion for collector Ronn Palm, and it is easy to see why. The first image presented by MI here is captioned as being the “finest image” in his collection. It is a quarter-plate ambrotype of a company of Union soldiers lined up in an unidentified town. The detail provided by the civilians watching the soldiers in their ranks adds interest to the image for modern viewers. The other outdoor images featured include men relaxing (including one eating eggs with his meal), artillery at the ready, and two other units standing in ranks. One was taken shortly before the start of the Gettysburg campaign.

Officers (pp. 28-30)
The final selection of images from Ronn Palm’s collection includes 10 images of officers, both individual and group portraits. Two that stand out includes Captain John Laughlin of the 104th Pennsylvania who is the subject of a carte de visite while holding a model of a siege gun. The other is Lt. Col. J.W. Lyman of the 203rd Pennsylvania with his toddler daughter, Libbie; Lyman was killed at Fort Fisher in January 1865.

Back Image
A half-plate ambrotype image features a militia officer who looks a great deal like General Daniel Harvey Hill of the Army of Northern Virginia.

The complete issue

Vol. VIII, No. 3
(32 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
An unidentified Union field-grade officer, wearing his corps badge hanging from a ribbon, which denotes him as a staff officer.

Editor’s Desk (p. 1)
In this issue, the editor explains that issues of Military Images beginning with the January-February 1986 issue will be included in the ABC-CLIO index and abstract service. Abstracts of articles will be published in Historical Abstracts as well.

Mail Call (p. 3)
The controversy regarding the photograph of the unidentified Confederate Marine is concluded with a letter from a motion picture special effects artist. He took the images and ran them through some detailed photographic tests and found that the image is indeed that of Lt. David Raney. Brian Pohanka also provides newly found evidence that expands on his biography of Miles Keogh from the previous issue of MI: a letter that proves the rumor that Keogh had a premonition about his death. Other letters include questions regarding Missouri militia battle shirts and a request for help finding information about a Texan in the 9^th Texas Cavalry.

Passing in Review (p. 5)
Two items are included, beginning with the addition of five books written by Philip Katcher to the Man-at-Arms series by Osprey. His contributions include four books on the uniforms and equipment of the Civil War and one on the U.S. Cavalry on the Plains. The book WAR by Gwynne Dwyer is the second item reviewed. The volume, which covers the history of warfare from Armageddon in 1480 B.C. to the current era of nuclear warfare, also following his miniseries of the same name. A short note at the end of the feature lets readers know that Son of the Morning Star: Custer and the Little Bighorn by Evan Connell has been released again in paperback with 24 photographs.

More Georgians in Gray: Brief Biographies of Confederate Soldiers, Part II by Keith Bohannon (pp. 6-13)
Fifteen different images, including some of siblings, illustrate the stories of these soldiers who fought for Georgia during the Civil War. The men came from a variety of backgrounds, from young farm boys to school teachers to the sons of the landed elite, and saw action from First Manassas to the horrific fighting at the Devil’s Den at Gettysburg to the surrender at Appomattox. A few died of disease, some in battle, and many resumed their lives as honored members of their communities after the war.

Massachusetts Mystery Medal by Howard Michael Madaus (pp. 14-15)
This article describes a very unique device worn by members of the 1st Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry, apparently first in use during the summer of 1863. Seen on the uniforms of five members of the unit, the medal appears to be a complete minie ball attached to a ribbon with a dark diagonal stripe on a square ribbon, with a bar attachment to a second piece of the same ribbon which is attached to a metal shield. The author of the article requests any information from the readership that could provide more light on the meaning of this interesting mystery medal.

Corps Badges of the Civil War, Part III: XI through XXV Corps by Wendell W. Lang, Jr. (pp. 16-26)
The final fifteen remaining Federal corps badges are the topic of this article. The author reminds the readers that a few of the corps (XIII and XXI) never adopted a corps badge and that some of the new corps adopted an old badge (the XX took on the badge of the XII) and others adopted new badges. Some of the men would wear their old corps badge even when their corps was integrated into a new one, so identification can be confusing at times. It is suggested that care be taken by collectors to use a magnifying glass to get as much detail about a corps badge as possible in order to make correct identification; some manufacturers even would put symbols on metal discs, which can also lead to misidentifications. The images included with the article show the crescent of the XI Corps, the five-pointed star of the XII Corps, the acorn of the XIV, the cartridge box of the XV, the symbol of the XVI (a circle which is said to have four minie ball cuts to make a rough cross), the second badge (an arrow) of the XVII Corps, the “foliate” cross badge of the XVIII, the initial four-pointed star of the XIX Corps, the unofficial five-leafed cross of the XXII, the escutcheon of the XXIII Corps, the heart-shaped badge of the XXIV, and the square within a square of the XXV Corps.

The Tenth Legion by Robert W. Fulmer (p. 29)
The Civil War saw the attempt to raise “legion” sized combined arms units, with approximately 1000 men organized into eight infantry companies along with a company of cavalry and one of artillery batteries. The Confederate legions (Hampton’s and Cobb’s Legions) are generally well-known, but the Union also raised one as well. The Tenth Legion was raised from Orange and Sullivan counties in New York, and its members wore a large shield with an “X” emblazoned on it, not to be confused with the X Corps badge. The color of the shield designated the combat arm the soldier belonged to: sky blue for infantry, green for rifle companies, orange for cavalry, red for artillery. The end of 1861 saw the recognition that a legion was unwieldy for the kind of fighting that was underway, so the Tenth Legion was broken up and its component parts being redistributed.

Stragglers (p. 31)
Military Images published in July-August 1981 (Vol. III, No. 1) a photograph of what was said to be a relaxed “Stonewall” Jackson standing along a fence in camp. The original quarter-plate ambrotype, stolen from the estate of Louise Briscoe, caused a sensation, with many not believing that the scruffy man wearing no rank could be Jackson. MI asked the reader who made the definitive identification of Lt. Raney (see “Mail Call”) to do the same kind of photo identification of this image. Mr. Fleming compared the image to four known images of “Stonewall” and his verdict: the figure in question is most definitely Thomas J. Jackson.

Back Image
The back of the issue features a ninth-plate ambrotype of an unidentified antebellum militia infantryman in a uniform typical of militia from North Carolina and Virginia. The bugle insignia was used by militia to designate rifle companies.

The complete issue

Vol. VIII, No. 2
(32 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
The full-length image of Christopher John Smith of the 3rd New Jersey Cavalry Regiment, also known as the 1st United States Hussars is the featured image on the cover of the issue. The 3rd New Jersey was also known as the “Butterfly Regiment” due to their elaborate uniforms, which can be easily seen in this image.

Editor’s Desk (p. 1)
The editor begins by introducing this second all-cavalry issue of Military Images, providing an overview of the featured articles. He also describes some of the highlights of the year’s Gettysburg exhibit over the July 4th weekend, including an educational exhibit by William Adams of Massachusetts that featured a collection of faked items such as muskets and frock coats, hoping to show collectors how to spot actual period items from reproductions. The editor announced the collaboration of MI with the Japanese military history magazine PX; they will be reprinting Japanese translations of MI articles in their publication. Lastly, the editor encourages the readership to contact their U.S. Senator and voice support for the donation of the Taney Farm to the Gettysburg NPS site.

Mail Call (pp. 2-3)
Letters to the editor include some corrections on identifications of past images as well as some congratulatory letters from readers. One reader from South Africa provided some background information on the development of Hussar uniforms. Two lengthy letters continue the discussion regarding the possible identity of a Confederate States Marine Corps lieutenant as being Lt. David Raney of Mobile, Alabama.

The Darkroom (p. 4)
Guidance regarding the repair of wooden cases which have broken hinges covered by paper is provided.

Passing in Review (p. 5)
Two different publications are reviewed, beginning with Old Abe the War Eagle by Richard H. Zeitlin. “Old Abe” was the mascot of the 8th Wisconsin Infantry Regiment during the Civil War, and this volume does more than provide a history of the famous bald eagle. It is a well-recommended regimental history of the 8th that takes it past the Civil War and into its history in the West, relying on many primary source accounts. The second publication is Civil War Commanders by Dean S. Thomas, a small reference of 105 Union and Confederate commanders. The intention was to highlight a number of notable commanders along with some uncommon images, although the reviewer does admit that a few choices made by the author seem unusual. Identical information is provided about each commander (e.g. basic biographical information, West Point attendance and standing, battle and campaign participation, etc.) making this a very nice short reference.

Vignette: John Ring, His Mark by Chris Nelson (pp. 6-7)
An image of a Union cavalryman in confident pose and a copy of enlistment papers provide the background of the story of John Ring, a South African sailor who volunteered for service in the United States Army on July 6, 1864. Private Ring was 26 years of age and while it is not known why he left the sea to join the 4th Massachusetts Cavalry, it can be inferred that he was an illiterate, as his “mark” serves as his signature on the enlistment paperwork. His service record shows that Ring served as a courier and orderly for most of his time in service, including a stint in the “Flying Hospital” at Camp Lee in Richmond. Like many servicemen, he apparently left the army when he felt his time had been served; his service record shows he left about August 13, 1865 with approximately $69.11 worth of ordnance and supplies in his possession. Nothing more is heard of from Private John Ring until 1923, when a request from a Massachusetts congressional member led to desertion charges being dropped.

Teddy’s Troopers: A look at the Rough Riders of 1898 by John Sickles (pp. 8-10)
A collection of five images shows some of the take of the independent cavalry regiment organized by Theodore Roosevelt. The article outlines some of the eclectic mix of Americans collected to form the “Rough Riders” who served with Roosevelt in the Spanish-American War under the leadership of Leonard Wood and former Confederate general “Fighting Joe” Wheeler. Fearing that they might not make it to the fight, two of the images show the Tampa encampment and then the troopers on the crowded deck and rigging of the Yucatan; they left the horses behind to get on a transport to Cuba.

The 1st D.C. Cavalry by Richard Carlile (pp. 11-13)
The only regiment of cavalry recruited in the District of Columbia was originally to only be used in that location, under the command of the War Department. Known as “Baker’s Mounted Rangers” and recruited between June and December 1863, Colonel Lafayette C. Baker’s men were an unusual group, actually made up of mostly Maine men. As they were armed with the powerful Henry repeating rifle, only half of the regiment was initially mounted. They also ended up serving outside of the District, taking part in the Weldon Railroad in May 1864 and the Siege of Petersburg later that year. Eventually, the Maine elements were transferred to the First Maine Cavalry, leaving the D.C. companies to remain with the Army of the Potomac. Seven images of D.C. Cavalry troopers accompany the article.

Vignette: Henry Seafferman, 7th Cavalry by George Hart (p. 14)
Born in France and immigrating to Indiana as a child, Henry Seafferman served with the 2nd United States Cavalry before the Civil War began. During the Civil War, he was with the 5th as it was redesignated, serving in the Army of the Potomac. The sixth-plate tintype image that accompanies this vignette shows a young man armed with a bayonetted rifle and pistol taken during this time. After the war, Seafferman enlisted with the 7th Cavalry under Custer. Noted by the First Sergeant of G troop as being one of the best shots in the unit, Seafferman was killed during the Battle of Little Bighorn on June 25, 1876.

Myles Keogh by Brian Pohanka (pp. 15-24)
Ten images accompany this biographic article that recounts the life and career of Myles Keogh, the Irish-born cavalry officer who was part of George Armstrong Custer’s 7th Cavalry. Coming from a comfortable background, Keogh joined 1400 other Irishmen to fight in defense of Pope Pius IX against Giuseppe Garibaldi’s revolutionaries in May 1860. The article follows Keogh’s progress as a lieutenant in the Zouaves of the Papal Guard, known as the Company of St. Patrick to his coming to the United States and his career as a member of several generals’ staffs, including John Buford and George Stoneman. Captured and exchanged at one point during the war, Keogh was known not only for his dashing appearance, but for his bravery on the field of battle. The article also details his career after the war in the service of the 7th Cavalry, but also delves into some of the more private side of Keogh, including his melancholy, apparent alcoholism, and his disappointment in romance. Keogh is often remembered as the owner of the cavalry mount Commanche, the only “survivor” of the Little Bighorn disaster. That is but one chapter of a much storied career.

The Search for Lt. Crow by John Ertzgaard (p. 25)
The image accompanying the article was the subject of a long search, and was eventually found to be that of Lt. William Porter Crow, Company B of the 6th Kentucky Cavalry, under the command of John Hunt Morgan. The author of the article outlines his search and provides the military background of Lt. Crow, who was captured during Morgan’s raid into Ohio in the summer of 1863. The long incarceration following his capture led to his early death from lung disease in November of 1865.

Stragglers (pp. 26-28)
This issue’s version of “Stragglers” includes two images that are offered as “Pop Quiz No. 317” and “Pop Quiz No. 318” along with an image of three Federal artillerists posing while playing cards. The background of the two quiz images highlight groups that often were given military-type organizations, such as the Western Union Telegraphic Expedition (No. 317) and possibly the Masonic group called the Knights of Gideon (No, 318).

Back Image
A unique carte de visite image shows a Union cavalryman holding onto the rein of a horse painted onto a backdrop of canvas.

The complete issue

Vol. XXVI, No. 5
(40 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
A sixth-plate ambrotype from the David W. Vaughan collection is a portrait of Pvt. James M. Hart of Crenshaw’s Virginia Battery. This may be the only known image of a soldier clad in Confederate regulation rain gear.

Table of Contents (p. 1)

Editor’s Desk (p. 2)
The editor notes the 143^rd anniversary of the Battle of Antietam and highlights the collection of Brian Boeve, who has long had an interest in this pivotal engagement. A letter to the editor discusses a 75^th anniversary Gettysburg Reunion Medal worn by a bugler pictured in the last issue.

Cover Story (p. 3)
James Malcolm Hart, who suffered a wound at the Battle of Fredericksburg, is the subject of a biographical sketch.

Passing in Review (pp. 4-5)
Two books are reviewed. Custer’s Southern Officer: Captain George D. Wallace, 7^th U.S. Cavalry by John D. Mackintosh praises the author for giving Wallace his due after years of obscurity. The Civil War Up Close: Thousands of Curious, Obscure, and Fascinating Facts About the War America Could Never Win by Donald Cartmell is described as a useful book even though it sheds little new light on familiar topics.

Shiloh, “Place of Peace” by Brian Boeve (pp. 6-12)
A gallery of nine soldier portraits is presented, each illustrated with informative captions. All of the men are identified. They include John Keppel, John Eichelberger and Lemuel Donovan of the 2^nd Iowa Infantry, Christie Babbitt and James Robbins of the 55^th Illinois Infantry, Edward Cooper of the 23^rd Missouri Infantry, George Reiflin of the 24^th Indiana Infantry, Charles A. Johnson of the 12^th Illinois Infantry and Jesse Sherer of the 5^th Ohio Cavalry.

Review at Fort Smith, Arkansas, November 12, 1864 by Jules Martino (pp. 13-17)
A brief history of Fort Smith during the Civil War years is illustrated by six quarter-plate outdoor tintypes that include soldiers from the 12^th and 13^th Kansas infantries and the 2^nd Kansas Battery. Also included is a Library of Congress photo of Union Gen. Francis J. Herron, who inspected the soldiers shown in the tintypes.

Long Soldier by Charles G. Markantes (pp. 18-19)
A famous photograph of Lt. Col. George A. Custer and friends taken in July 1875 includes a Native American originally identified as Bloody Knife. He served Custer as a scout. An article in the Spring 2004 issue of Past Times magazine suggested that the Native American was unidentified. The author suggests that the man is actually Long Soldier and supports his theory with primary source material and other information.

Finding Major Robert C. Wallace of the 5^th Michigan Cavalry by John Peter Beckendorf (pp. 20-24)
In this first part of Wallace’s story, the author tells the story of the life and military experiences of the Scottish-born soldier who left behind his memoirs upon his death in 1928. Three portraits of Walter Stevenson, which were at one time thought to be likenesses of Wallace, are included. Also included are two actual portraits of Wallace and two staff images in which Wallace is pictured.

Five Dilley Brothers Go to War by J. Dale West (pp. 25-31)
The wartime odyssey of the five Dilley brothers from Yazoo County, Mississippi, traces the service of Joseph Andrew, Robert William and Samuel Usher Dilley, who all served in the 12^th Mississippi Infantry, Abraham Thomas Dilley, who served in Jones’ Cavalry, Mississippi State Troops, and Eugene Perry Dilley of the 29^th Mississippi Infantry. Illustrations include a wartime ambrotype of Robert and Samuel, a portrait of Abraham in uniform and a post-war image of Joseph.

Uniforms & History by Michael J. McAfee (p. 32)
In “The First Regiment of Mounted Rifles, New York Volunteers,” McAfee presents a brief history of the regiments and a description of the uniforms worn by the men. A carte de visite of two soldiers from the 1^st, wearing distinctive caps adorned with the brass letters MR, illustrates the text.

The Confederate Soldier (p. 33)
A sixth-plate ambrotype from the David W. Vaughan collection is a portrait of two young soldiers who served in Capt. T.B. Ferguson’s Company of the 3^rd South Carolina Infantry.

Stragglers (pp. 34-38)
Nine images are featured in this issue, including four unidentified Confederates and two identified Union soldiers, Principal Musician Charles E. Hastings of the 106^th New York Infantry and Capt. William Howland of the 127h New York Infantry. Another Civil War image is a double exposure carte de visite of an elderly man named John S. Wilkerson or Wilkenson. In one half of the image he plays a fife and in the other a drum. Two post-Civil War images include an 1898 portrait of Corp. Adrian Ellery Riley of the Astor Battery and a World War I era soldier named Alphonse Bissonett.

Sutler’s Row (p. 39)

The Last Shot (p. 40)
A tintype from the Bill Lee collection pictures an unidentified Union musician with his drum. In the foreground can be seen the leg and arm of a soldier in a chair, perhaps waiting to have his photograph made. In the background two overlapping backdrops are visible.

The complete issue

Vol. XXXIV, No. 2
(64 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Digital edition (premium access)
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
A previously unpublished quarter-plate tintype of Jefferson Davis attributed to photographer Jesse H. Whitehurst of Washington, D.C., from the collection of John O’Brien.
Download (free)

Table of Contents (p. 1)
Download (free)

Editor’s Desk (p. 2)
The editor notes that thousands of portrait photographs of soldiers and sailors have been published in the magazine since it was founded in 1979. Enlisted men from all walks of life and of all ranks compose the vast majority of images, though likenesses of nurses, vivandières and patriotic persons have graced our pages. In every case, each image and its associated narrative is a microhistory —a historical investigation on the individual level. They are windows that shed light on the larger themes of the American experience.
Download (free)

Mail Call (p. 3)
Feedback includes a misidentified Zouave, a Wisconsin infantryman, more on a local Civil War hero and efforts to honor his memory and a note about surcingles.
Download (free)

Passing in Review (p. 4)
Soldier stories are freshly mined nuggets of history in a new book by John Banks, Hidden History of Connecticut Union Soldiers (Arcadia Publishing). A longtime journalist and blogger, Banks maximizes his skill as a reporter and writer to tell representative stories of Connecticut Yankees. His compelling narratives better our appreciation of the human cost of war for soldiers and families.
Download (free)

On the Eve of War: Previously Unknown Portraits of Jefferson and Varina Davis Come to Light by John O’Brien (pp. 6-9)
Previously unpublished portraits capture future Confederate Commander-In-Chief Jefferson Davis and first lady Varina Howell Davis at a critical moment in history. The pair of quarter-plate tintypes, part of the John O’Brien, have an extraordinary provenance that traces to an unexpected source—U.S. Secretary of the Navy Gideon Welles.

The Absolute Truth of Photos by William C. Davis (p. 10)
A reflection on the Jefferson Davis tintype: “Today, we are the first Americans to see, for the first time, the weary and pained face of the man destined to lead a lost cause whose echoes reverberate still, and whose issues at root still trouble our society in the 21st century.”

On the Eve of a Crossroads by Joan E. Cashin (p. 11)
A reflection on the Davis tintypes with emphasis on the portrait of Varina Howell Davis: “They were both pro-slavery, believing that the Constitution protected the institution, but she did not share his growing hostility towards the North.”

Custer’s West Virginia Red Ties: The Life and Times of the 3rd West Virginia Cavalry by Richard A. Wolfe (pp. 12-17)
The history of the 3rd begins with a military company formed in the pro-Union western counties of Virginia and ends in the Shenandoah Valley fighting under the command of flamboyant Maj. Gen. George Armstrong Custer.

The Honored Few (p. 18)
Hilary Beyer, a second lieutenant in Company H of the 90th Pennsylvania Infantry, proved his courage in the infamous Cornfield at the Battle of Antietam. His actions resulted in the Medal of Honor.

The Great Outdoors: Civil War Soldiers at Work, Rest and Play by C. Paul Loane (pp. 20-30)
Images of soldiers pictured in camp, on campaign and other locations have always held a special interest for collector C. Paul Loane. “There is more going on than just the soldiers standing there,” Loane explains. “They are particularly helpful in seeing just what kind of environment the soldiers were in or what gear they really did use,” he observes.

Antebellum Warriors (p. 31)
A sixth-plate daguerreotype from the Ron Field collection pictures a man dressed in clothing that makes it difficult to discern whether he is a soldier or a civilian.

Held Hostage in Virginia: A Union Captain Becomes a Casualty in a Battle of Wits Between Jefferson Davis and John Pope by Scott Valentine (pp. 32-34)
Samuel Miller Quincy suffered a wound and fell into enemy hands after his 2nd Massachusetts Infantry was routed at the Battle of Cedar Mountain on Aug.9, 1862. He could not have known that he would be treated not as a prisoner of war, but as a hostage in a deadly game with no ground rules.

Union Wives and Their Generals by Tom Glass (pp. 35-43)
Nearly all the generals who served the North during the Civil War were married. Left behind at home, their wives cared for families, farms, businesses and relatives. A few accompanied their husbands into fields of action. Many generals seemed eager to have their betrothed with them as frequently as possible. And often, the wives of generals had greater access to headquarters than junior officers. A representative sample of portraits of these military couples.

“A Hideous Dream” by John Banks (pp. 44-46)
In an exclusive excerpt from Hidden History of Connecticut Union Soldiers by John Banks, a family is divided by two brothers, one who fought for the North and another for the South.

Stragglers (pp. 47-50)
A total of eight distinctive and unique images from MI contributors includes a full-plate ambrotype of a Louisiana officer, a sixth-plate tintype of a Chausser, a sixth-plate ambrotype of a federal infantryman with his pocket watch and a carte de visite of Harper’s Weekly illustrator Theodore R. Davis seated upon Lookout Mountain with a group of Union staff officers.

Photo Sleuth by Kurt Luther (pp. 52-54)
The gift of a soldier carte de visite with distinctive markings—red ink numbers in the lower left corner and brass clips at the top and bottom of the mount—is the starting point for the story of the Dead Letter Office, a special branch of the U.S. Post Office charged with solving undeliverable mail mysteries.

An Album of Ardent Patriots: Company B, 33rd Illinois Infantry by Jim Hennessey (pp. 56-57)
Untold numbers of albums filled with soldier photos are scattered across the country, and they have survived more than 150 years. Here are the stories of the men pictured in one of them.

Words Exchanged in an Ambulance by Ronald S. Coddington (pp. 58-60)
In the wake of fighting in Virginia during the spring campaign of 1864, two wounded soldiers shared an ambulance. A grizzled New Hampshire sergeant lay on one side and a young South Carolina private on the other. The two soldiers conversed and found common ground on the way to an uncertain future.

Uniforms & History by Michael J. McAfee (pp. 61-62)
Napoleon purportedly commented that an army travels on its stomach. If that was the case, the commissary officers keep it moving. Likewise, ordnance officers maintain the flow of weapons and ammunition, and inspectors make certain the men and their equipment are up to snuff and ready for action. The vital work of officers of both the General Staff and regimental staffs is often overlooked by the average Civil War buff. McAfee explores the variations of uniforms of these underappreciated staffers.

The Last Shot (p. 64)
Collector Gary Bart shares an unusual carte de visite of a New York man dressed in a dress and shawl. The image is dated June 11, 1865, about a month after Confederate President Jefferson Davis was captured wearing his wife’s overcoat.

The complete issue

Vol. XXVI, No. 3
(40 pages)

Print edition: Visit our store to check availability
Digital edition: Visit JSTOR.org to purchase
Subscribe to MI
Explore the MI Archives: Browse | Advanced search | Tutorial

Inside

Cover image
From the collection of Chris Nelson, an unusual unidentified trick photography carte de visite by J. Jones, Rendezvous of Distribution, Va.

Table of Contents (p. 1)

Editor’s Desk (p. 2)
The editor is gratified by the overwhelmingly positive response to the recent Georgia issue and notes that an Ohio-themed state issue will be featured next.

Passing in Review (pp. 4-5)
Two books are reviewed and both are recommended. Faces of the Civil War: An Album of Union Soldiers and Their Stories by Ronald S. Coddington offers “valuable insights into the experiences of seventy-seven Union ‘faces of war.’” Great Maps of the Civil War, Pivotal Battles and Campaigns Featuring 32 Removable Maps by William J. Miller is a “handsomely produced volume” that is well-researched and colorful.

The Flag of the 17^th Texas Consolidated Cavalry by John Sickles (pp. 6-7)
A photograph taken at Lufkin, Texas, on Sept. 21, 1929, depicts the bullet and shell torn flag of the regiment held by two of its veterans, W.P. Fears and E.W.H. Parker. A one-page history of the 17^th is included.

“Slow Trot” Thomas Between Wars: Accurately Dating an Antebellum Image by Gregory J.W. Urwin (pp. 8-11)
An 1853-1854 daguerreotype by Mathew B. Brady of future Civil War Gen. George Henry Thomas pictures the officer as a brevet major in the 3^rd U.S. Artillery. A three-part narrative accompanies the image. “The Man” is a biographical sketch of Thomas from his beginnings in Virginia to his rise to fame as “The Rock of Chickamauga” and his post-war years. “The Image” is a physical description of the image and case. “Dating the Image” is a description of how the author, a professor of history at Temple University, concluded that the image was made by Brady in the 1853-1854 timeframe—a year earlier than the 1855 date given by the curator of photographs at the National Portrait Gallery in the late 1970s.

The 12^th Kansas Infantry “Jayhawkers” by J. Dale West (pp. 12-17)
An album of 25 soldiers who served in the regiment includes 8 identified men: 1^st Lt. William A. Welles of Company C, Capt. Nick L. Benter of Company C, Sgt. Maj. Clarkson Reynolds, 1^st Lt. and Regimental Quartermaster Joshua Clayton, 2^nd Lt. Samuel S. Kirkham of Company C, 1^st Lt. William B. Nichols of Company C, Pct. Enos Ingle of Company D and Brig. Gen. John Edwards.

The Death of John Kent C.S.A. by Mahlon Nichols (p. 18)
A biographical sketch of Kent, a private in the 2^nd Missouri Infantry, includes a touching obituary with his final words, “I die in a good cause; tell my friends good-bye.” The sketch is illustrated with a hard-plate image of Kent in civilian dress.

“Red,” The Story of Lt. James D. Bebout: Gridiron Star, All-American Hero by John W. Turner (pp. 19-21)
A standout football player at Penn State from 1910-1914, Bebout graduated with a degree in agriculture and went to work for the federal government. After war was declared against Germany during World War I, he joined the U.S. army as an officer and was assigned to Company D of the 318^th Infantry of the 80^th Division. In May 1918, Bebout sailed for France with his division. Four months later, on Sept. 29, he was killed during the fighting at Bethincourt. Included in the story is a 1919 letter written by Bebout’s friend and fellow officer, Capt. E.C. Shively. It describes Bebout’s death and other wartime reflections of the late Penn State star.

Contributions to the War Effort from Shrewsbury, New Jersey by Thomas J. Moeller (pp. 23-25)
The identities of the veterans pictured in a circa 1884 photograph of the members of Grand Army of the Republic Post 61 in Shrewsbury, N.J., are not known. The author however has a list of the names of all the membership, and notes that “their personal stories run the spectrum of New Jersey’s military service during the Civil War. Several stories follow, with wartime images of 2^nd Lt. William Conover and 1^st Lt. William H. Foster of the 14^th New Jersey Infantry and Capt. Samuel Tucker Sleeper of the 11^th New Jersey Infantry.

William Worth Belknap, Fallen Hero by Thomas Gaard (pp. 26-31)
Belknap, the author states, “is best known as the Secretary of War in the Grant Administration. He was charged with corruption, resigned his position and was impeached by the House of Representatives.” His fall from grace overshadows a distinguished war record that includes the Battle of Shiloh, during which he suffered a serious wound, and the campaigns of Vicksburg and Atlanta. Belknap’s story is illustrated with an early war albumen print of him as an officer in the 15^th Iowa Infantry, an image of Belknap as a brigadier general with two orderlies, a group portrait of the general with his staff officers and other images.

Uniforms & History by Michael J. McAfee (pp. 32-33)
In the “165^th New York Volunteer Infantry, 1862-1865, Second Duryea Zouaves,” McAfee recounts the history of the regiment and describes their distinctive uniforms. Three portraits are included, an unidentified private, 1^st Lt. Gustavus F. Linquist and 2^nd Lt. Charles Carville.

Stragglers (p. 34-38)
A total of 16 images are featured—Nine from the Civil War, one from about 1901, and six from World War I. Several of the latter portraits are identified. The identities of two of men in a group of nine generals in a circa 1918-1919 portrait are known: Benjamin Foulois, Chief of the Air Service, AEF, and Manus McCloskey, a field artillery brigade commander in the 77^th Division. Other identified men included a Japanese-American Doughboy, Pvt. Hatsuko Kasagi, Pvt. Stephen Savko of the Medical Department of Base Hospital #80 and Pvt. Frank Berkavich.

Sutler’s Row (p. 39-40)